Headless Horseman Hay Ride - Fishers, IN

Headless Horseman Hay Ride is part of the Conner Prairie history park.  The haunted attraction runs Thursday through Sunday nights in October.   Lots of fun loving ghouls on this ride. Save some money and order tickets online for less. Guests are invited to wear their costumes this year. Their daytime hay ride is for the entire family and runs from 10 am to 5 pm.  The Headless Horseman leaves Sleepy Hallow behind to turn Conner Prairie into “Conner Scairie.” Families can brave a haunted hayride and the eerie soothsaying in the mystic tent. With food that is so delicious, even Ichabod Crane would stop for a gooey caramel apple, this annual event is a great family tradition in central Indiana. Guests will enjoy nightly thrills that include a haunted hayride, pumpkin bowling, a Legend of Sleepy Hollow marionette show, catapulting pumpkins and scary-o-ke singing. Several new events will be offered this year, including visits from Sammy Terry, an enthralling magician, nightly showings of Disney’s “Legend of Sleepy Hollow” film and a carnival games midway. S’mores can be made over a fire (additional cost) and there will even be the opportunity to taste sautéed insects!

Visit Website

Online Ratings

Conner Prairie
Conner Prairie 4.5 star rating 120 reviews
Tank G.'s Review Tank G.
5.0 star rating

Wow! This place is amazing. It is like fitting 10 pounds in a 5 pound bag. You can purchase tickets in person at the Welcome Center, but I recommend...

Read Full Review
Tiffany M.'s Review Tiffany M.
5.0 star rating

Wow. When you think about the size of this operation and the number of people that bring this living museum to life, it's very impressive! Eli Lily started...

Read Full Review
Teri W.'s Review Teri W.
4.0 star rating

What a fun time at Connor Prairie's Merry Prairie 2020!!!!!

This was our first time to Connor Prairie. We had no idea what to expect especially in this...

Read Full Review


Watch a Video

Here is a video from the past that provides information about a prior event. We hope you find it helpful in deciding whether you should attend the event this year.

Update this Information

We are testing out the ability to have event owners update their own listings. If you own or run this haunted attraction, please use the link below to update. Thanks!

Edit Headless Horseman Hay Ride

Thank you for helping keep our information up to date.

Nearby Haunted Houses

Other Indiana Haunted Houses