Benners Farm - East Setauket, NY

Limited opening during the virus beginning in late September.  They feature pumpkin picking, hayrides, live music, and cider making. This 15 acre private farm has many weekend festivals throughout the summer and fall. It is located at 56 Gnarled Hollow Rd., E Setauket, NY. It is about 50 miles east of Queens.

Visit Website

Latest Information from Facebook

Online Ratings

Benner's Farm
Benner's Farm 4.5 star rating 29 reviews
Buzz O.'s Review Buzz O.
5.0 star rating

Benners Farm has been a mainstay of the Three Village community for decades and has been a working farm for over 250 years. The childrens and adults...

Read Full Review
Michelle P.'s Review Michelle P.
5.0 star rating

This is such a special farm. Family owned- my hubby worked here when he was a teenager. Definitely a family favorite! We love the childrens classes!!!

Read Full Review
Genie M.'s Review Genie M.
5.0 star rating

A great family farm. The family and staff are welcoming and willing to share so much information. They are organized. When you check in you receive a map ....

Read Full Review


Watch a Video

Here is a video from the past that provides information about a prior event. We hope you find it helpful in deciding whether you should attend the event this year.

Nearby Farms

Other NY Pumpkin Patches