Milk Pail - Water Mill, NY

A local staple that is family owned and operated. U-pick apple orchard and pumpkin field Friday through Sunday in September and October beginning Labor Day. More than 20 apple varieties available for picking – and they are grown on dwarf trees, making it easy to pick no matter your height. They have more than 60 different varieties of pumpkins and gourds. Their apple cider and donuts garner a lot of praise in reviews.

Visit Website

Latest Information from Facebook

Online Ratings

Estina R.'s Review Estina R.
5.0 star rating

What a lovely spot to grab a range of items from fruit (...very beautifully grown, special items), huge selection of dairy and cheese and baked...

Read Full Review
yogi s.'s Review yogi s.
1.0 star rating

If I could give this place no stars, I would!

I discovered the most amazing cookies at this spot in the Hamptons while I was working in Bridgehampton over...

Read Full Review
Daniel G.'s Review Daniel G.
1.0 star rating

The Milk Pail was so rude to me and my family! My mother, mind you she is an elder, was demanded to walk out with her emotional support dog to the entrance...

Read Full Review


Nearby Farms

Other NY Pumpkin Patches